Perspective published on November 1, 2021
College Towns Provide Economic Resilience
- The local economic benefits of higher education are numerous.
- They can be set against some cities’ backdrop of long-term economic and social decline.
- What challenges has COVID-19 created for higher ed and local economic resiliency?
Colleges and universities play critical roles in their local economies. Studies support the premise that investments by college towns and cities to support local higher education pay dividends to surrounding economies, including at critical times, such as during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The local economic benefits of higher education can be set against a backdrop of economic and social decline in some cities over decades, as manufacturing operations migrated away from many major industrial U.S. cities and states. Struggles that followed sometimes launched downward economic spirals worsened by negative momentum of population declines, which proved difficult to halt or reverse.
Yet, in college towns, the operation of a college or university often plays the role of economic engine. In addition to the influx of students, parents, and visitors and the more permanent presence of faculty and staff, colleges and universities can attract new permanent residents as well as encourage the growth of businesses, arts, and additional social benefits in the local area.
Colleges and Universities as Economic Drivers
Research by the Brookings Institution for The Wall Street Journal suggests some notable exceptions to this pattern.1 The study found that roughly half of manufacturing-heavy areas that lost jobs but maintained steady employment growth since 2000 are home to a major research university. In these instances, the presence of a major research university supported economic activity in otherwise struggling towns where traditional manufacturing was declining.
Large research universities often serve as innovation engines, the research suggested, helping to drive advancements that private industry may sustained. Colleges and universities can provide myriad local stimuli including a stable pipeline of knowledge, ideas, entrepreneurship, and skilled residents. These communities are often more inclusive as well, offering opportunities to diverse residents with a variety of skills across a range of professional and social strata.
The economic and social dynamism can be strong enough to offset other factors: short-term like pandemic-imposed business and social restrictions and long-term such as a economic decline.
Capturing tuition, fees and other expenditures from out-of-state and international students, and attracting well-educated, higher earners to a region helps to drive higher personal income and municipal revenues. Increasing populations can attract private investment that supports restaurants, retailers, and the arts.
A different but consistent perspective is offered by instances of colleges across the U.S. investing in their hometowns because the towns’ economic prospects affect the college’s outlook as well. These revitalization efforts are proactively pursued by colleges as mutually beneficial.
Efforts by small-town colleges include a range of creative measures. For example, colleges are admitting a selected group of local high school graduates by offering generous scholarships. They also encourage students to work with local organizations and businesses in efforts to gain real-world experience, while supporting the local community. Further, they often can establish partnerships with local employers to offer students real-world experience and networking opportunities, while supporting local labor levels and employers. In one instance, a college dean moved to an off-campus office in order to foster greater connections with the local community.
College Town Economies Remarkably COVID-resilient
More recently, in the face of the temporary but significant challenges posed by the economic shift prompted by COVID-19 in 2020 and 2021, college towns have been put to the test. Generally, the economic resilience of college towns is built around the positive presence of students, who rent dorms, houses, and apartments, and spend money in restaurants, bars, and local retail stores.
The students’ spending historically is complemented by professors and college administrators who buy homes and cars and plant longer-term roots in these towns. The economic spin-off is compounded by traditional annual events, including parents’ weekends, homecoming weekends, graduations, and football games.
COVID-19 shutdowns and forced closures of local campuses abruptly halted the activities in the spring of 2020. Fewer students and campus workers suppressed spending. However, a sampling of college towns across the country in August 7, 2020, revealed an ongoing level of economic resilience as reported by MarketWatch, in “Here’s why college towns are among the most economically resilient places in the country.”
For example, Corvallis, OR, home of Oregon State University, also supports more than two dozen software companies, thanks largely to the high volume of engineers who graduate from the school each year. A review of monthly U.S. Labor Department data reveals that the unemployment rate for Corvallis from January through May 2021 was 1.0 to 1.8 percentage points below that of Oregon’s statewide average. In May, for example, Corvallis had a 4.0 percent unemployment rate while unemployment for Oregon overall was at 5.8 percent.
Similarly, Rochester, NY, home of the University of Rochester, a renowned research university, generates a highly educated workforce that supports key industries including optics, imaging, energy innovation, software and information technology services. For the first five months of 2021, Rochester’s unemployment rate varied from 1.8 percentage points to 3.0 percentage points lower than the New York state average. In May 2021, for instance, Rochester’s unemployment rate was 5.8 percent, based on seasonally-adjusted Rochester Core-Based Statistical Area data.
Another small-town economic benefit brought about by the societal shifts in response to the pandemic is an increased openness and desire to telecommute for many white-collar workers, attracted to the lower cost of living and higher quality of life often associated with small towns.
While some areas in the U.S. struggled more than others due long-term trends such as globalization and short-term challenges such as COVID-19, many other states, cities and towns have reasons to be optimistic. In particular, colleges and universities hold great potential to fuel social and economic well-being across the country, especially over the long term.
 “There’s an Antidote to America’s Long Economic Malaise: College Towns,” December 12, 2016
#273021 Updated 10-28-21
This material provides general and/or educational information and should not be construed as a solicitation or offer of Breckinridge services or products or as legal, tax or investment advice. The content is current as of the time of writing or as designated within the material. All information, including the opinions and views of Breckinridge, is subject to change without notice.
Any estimates, targets, and projections are based on Breckinridge research, analysis, and assumptions. No assurances can be made that any such estimate, target or projection will be accurate; actual results may differ substantially.
Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Breckinridge makes no assurances, warranties or representations that any strategies described herein will meet their investment objectives or incur any profits. Any index results shown are for illustrative purposes and do not represent the performance of any specific investment. Indices are unmanaged and investors cannot directly invest in them. They do not reflect any management, custody, transaction or other expenses, and generally assume reinvestment of dividends, income and capital gains. Performance of indices may be more or less volatile than any investment strategy.
Performance results for Breckinridge’s investment strategies include the reinvestment of interest and any other earnings, but do not reflect any brokerage or trading costs a client would have paid. Results may not reflect the impact that any material market or economic factors would have had on the accounts during the time period. Due to differences in client restrictions, objectives, cash flows, and other such factors, individual client account performance may differ substantially from the performance presented.
All investments involve risk, including loss of principal. Diversification cannot assure a profit or protect against loss. Fixed income investments have varying degrees of credit risk, interest rate risk, default risk, and prepayment and extension risk. In general, bond prices rise when interest rates fall and vice versa. This effect is usually more pronounced for longer-term securities. Income from municipal bonds can be declared taxable because of unfavorable changes in tax laws, adverse interpretations by the IRS or state tax authorities, or noncompliant conduct of a bond issuer.
Breckinridge believes that the assessment of ESG risks, including those associated with climate change, can improve overall risk analysis. When integrating ESG analysis with traditional financial analysis, Breckinridge’s investment team will consider ESG factors but may conclude that other attributes outweigh the ESG considerations when making investment decisions.
There is no guarantee that integrating ESG analysis will improve risk-adjusted returns, lower portfolio volatility over any specific time period, or outperform the broader market or other strategies that do not utilize ESG analysis when selecting investments. The consideration of ESG factors may limit investment opportunities available to a portfolio. In addition, ESG data often lacks standardization, consistency and transparency and for certain companies such data may not be available, complete or accurate.
Breckinridge’s ESG analysis is based on third party data and Breckinridge analysts’ internal analysis. Analysts will review a variety of sources such as corporate sustainability reports, data subscriptions, and research reports to obtain available metrics for internally developed ESG frameworks. Qualitative ESG information is obtained from corporate sustainability reports, engagement discussion with corporate management teams, among others. A high sustainability rating does not mean it will be included in a portfolio, nor does it mean that a bond will provide profits or avoid losses.
Net Zero alignment and classifications are defined by Breckinridge and are subjective in nature. Although our classification methodology is informed by the Net Zero Investment Framework Implementation Guide as outlined by the Institutional Investors Group on Climate Change, it may not align with the methodology or definition used by other companies or advisors. Breckinridge is a member of the Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials and uses the financed emissions methodology to track, monitor and allocate emissions. These differences should be considered when comparing Net Zero application and strategies.
Targets and goals for Net Zero can change over time and could differ from individual client portfolios. Breckinridge will continue to invest in companies with exposure to fossil fuels; however, we may adjust our exposure to these types of investments based on net zero alignment and classifications over time.
Any specific securities mentioned are for illustrative and example only. They do not necessarily represent actual investments in any client portfolio.
The effectiveness of any tax management strategy is largely dependent on each client’s entire tax and investment profile, including investments made outside of Breckinridge’s advisory services. As such, there is a risk that the strategy used to reduce the tax liability of the client is not the most effective for every client. Breckinridge is not a tax advisor and does not provide personal tax advice. Investors should consult with their tax professionals regarding tax strategies and associated consequences.
Federal and local tax laws can change at any time. These changes can impact tax consequences for investors, who should consult with a tax professional before making any decisions.
The content may contain information taken from unaffiliated third-party sources. Breckinridge believes the data provided by unaffiliated third parties to be reliable but investors should conduct their own independent verification prior to use. Some economic and market conditions contained herein have been obtained from published sources and/or prepared by third parties, and in certain cases have not been updated through the date hereof. All information contained herein is subject to revision. Any third-party websites included in the content has been provided for reference only. Please see the Terms & Conditions page for third party licensing disclaimers.